YouTube’s ‘canceled’ stars are making comebacks with TikTok, podcasts and livestreams


For some influencers, being canceled isn’t career-ending– it’s the launchpad to a clean slate.

Three of the web’s most questionable stars have actually staged effective resurgences over the previous 2 years. Rather of altering themselves, they simply changed platforms.

James Charles, Tana Mongeau and Jeffree Star, each of whom have more than 20 million fans throughout different platforms, have actually discovered success in what may be considered their 2nd (or 3rd, or 4th) hacks at web popularity. The 3 were amongst the most-followed and most-criticized internet developers of a just recently passed period when weekly YouTube videos were the dominant format of influencer material.

They have actually all dealt with numerous cycles of extensive reaction, or what some individuals would call cancellation. Now, they are growing on other platforms and with other type of material, utilizing their restored goodwill to launch trips and items.

Star, who ended up being understood on YouTube for being a makeup and high-end design master, has actually welcomed TikTok Live, where he livestreams for hours at a time. Mongeau, who increased to YouTube prominence with overstated “Storytimes” about herself, introduced a podcast called “Cancelled” in 2021 that has an audience of countless listeners; she likewise jump-started a cross-country live trip. Charles, who shot to YouTube superstardom in the late 2010 s with his charm material, captivates near 38 million fans on TikTok and simply recently released an independent makeup line called “Painted,” backed by a few of the influencers who formerly signed up with the bandwagon of his failure.

Their resurgences highlight how, even on the web, where previous misbehaviours can follow individuals forever and “cancel culture” apparently controls, popular developers can shake off what as soon as appeared like career-ending debates– or perhaps utilize them to their benefit.

” If you’re being discussed and kept in mind, that is very important, particularly now that the market has actually ended up being so saturated. If individuals understand you by name, that is an advantage,” stated Crystal Abidin, a teacher of web research studies at Curtin University in Australia and ethnographer of web cultures.

Over the previous decade-plus, the foundation of online fame were routinely published YouTube videos, generally around 20 minutes long. With this formula, influencers had the ability to monetize their YouTube channels by making a portion of the earnings from advertisements that played in front of and throughout their videos.

That brought to life a material specific niche committed to discussing the everyday dramas around those developers, frequently called drama channels, which would cover whatever from concealed influencer sponsorships and unacceptable item launches to more major claims, like sexual violence and bigotry. Standard media outlets started covering these debates, too.

” They practically require promotion, whether it’s excellent or bad, simply to remain appropriate, to keep the views up and to keep their items offering,” stated Spill Sesh, a confidential popular culture news analyst who has more than 700,000 customers. “A great deal of them have actually made it their character that they’ve been canceled a million times.”

Around 2020, this reliable formula began to break down. A wave of prominent sexual misbehavior and bigotry claims swept the YouTube landscape, entangling a lot of the platform’s breakout stars throughout categories like vlogging and charm material. Charles was implicated of exchanging raunchy messages with minor fans, Star’s checkered past including racist material and accusations of sexual attack resurfaced, and Mongeau ultimately asked forgiveness in reaction to accusations of racist microaggressions towards Black developers.

Both Charles and Star have rejected accusations of sexual misbehavior and attack; Charles acknowledged that he messaged 2 individuals under the age of 18, however he stated that a minimum of one young boy lied about his age. Star had formerly acknowledged his history of racist material in a 2017 video. Still, their debates collected into a tidal bore of reaction in2020

” I understand a great deal of individuals do not wish to see influencers as stars, however they were being reported on by the mainstream media for the very first time ever,” stated Spill Sesh, who is thought about among the significant YouTube drama channels. “So their cancellations, the important things they were getting called out for, it was on a method larger scale than simply some little specific niche YouTube neighborhood.”

The fallout fasted. Charles’ whole YouTube channel was briefly demonetized, indicating he lost the capability to generate income from advertisements. Star briefly vanished from YouTube and, when he returned, his view count was significantly lower. The very same took place to Mongeau. All 3 had actually currently revealed– like lots of YouTubers do– their battle to keep constant money making on material that was often considered advertiser-unfriendly, often relatively without cause.

During the duration that he was demonetized on YouTube, Charles stopped publishing. He went back to the platform after 90 days (the duration that required to pass prior to he might reapply for money making), stating he utilized his time away to “in fact [hold] myself responsible” and “do a great deal of work behind the scenes.” Later on, Charles got rid of the very first video in which he acknowledged exchanging messages with minors.

Similarly, throughout his own debate in 2020, Star took numerous weeks off from publishing and returned with a video that didn’t address particular concerns or claims, however recommended taking legal action versus critics (none was apparently taken), and stated he had actually been taking part in self-reflection. Mongeau, after taking months off from publishing in 2020, said sorry to 2 Black developers who implicated her of being racist towards them– although she rejected being racist and stated her habits was because of immaturity. They didn’t accept her apology

Charles, Mongeau and Star still publish to YouTube, however their viewership has actually trended downward and they publish less often than they did at the height of their popularity, 4 or 5 years back.

” A great deal of them were simply tired of it,” stated Spill Sesh. “They type of disappeared, stopped truly publishing. I believe they truly disliked publishing on YouTube, due to the fact that the remarks had lots of reaction and individuals desiring them to resolve this, address that.”

But Mongeau has actually had the ability to restore a consistent following through her podcast, appropriately called “Cancelled,” in referral to the different debates she formerly withstood throughout her YouTube profession. The podcasts are approximately one to 2 hours long, a lot longer than Mongeau’s common material– which Spill Sesh stated becomes part of why “Cancelled” works, because Mongeau’s initial appeal was sharing off-the-cuff stories about her life.

Mongeau even took “Cancelled” on trip this year and is circumnavigating the U.S. Spill Sesh stated Mongeau’s audiences have actually pertained to anticipate her to be “cancelled,” so Mongeau can simply ask forgiveness throughout the next episode and her fans will continue tuning in. “Cancelled” is published on YouTube, in addition to being streamed on podcast platforms, consisting of Spotify. Mongeau just recently lost a “Cancelled” sponsorship from the language-learning app Babbel after she communicated an anecdote on the podcast about desiring a French red wine tourist guide “dead.” Mongeau was back the next episode with other sponsors.

From 2020 to 2023, Charles’ typical YouTube video view count fell by 10.1 million views. Charles made early inroads on TikTok, working together with the platform’s most significant stars in 2020, like Charli D’Amelio, and developing a following of almost 30 million individuals. Now, Charles’ TikTok videos are seen 5 times as much as his YouTube videos, usually.

Abidin stated that the introduction of TikTok as a dominant platform has actually made it harder for private influencers to stick out in the sea of developers, thanks in big part to the platform’s limitless, algorithm-driven “For You Page.” That has rather counterintuitively assisted developers like Star and Charles, who currently have significant name acknowledgment, while making it harder for brand-new developers to develop themselves.

” As an outcome, individuals are passively soaking up more material however not always discovering it unforgettable. In order to stick out now, you require to be the type of influencer or occasion that is ‘Google-able’ or ‘Google-worthy,'” Abidin stated. “I require to understand so I’m going to Google it or browse it on YouTube, which increase the engagement for what you’re doing.”

Star, on the other hand, didn’t begin entering TikTok till more just recently. After TikTok introduced TikTok Live, which enables audiences to tip developers little quantities of cash by sending out token “presents,” Star began investing hours at a time livestreaming to 10s of countless audiences. Star likewise utilizes the TikTok Shop function to market his items– like his makeup line– straight to his audience.

” Suddenly he’s opened this part of TikTok and he’s prospering on it,” Spill Sesh stated.

Since the height of his YouTube days, Star has actually relocated to Casper, Wyoming, where he owns a yak farm. He just recently opened a store where he offers makeup and yak items, consisting of yak meat.

” To individuals who saw him back in the drama days, they’re like, ‘What do you imply he’s growing?'” Spill Sesh stated. “Everyone on TikTok seeing resembles, ‘What do you imply you do not like farmer Jeffree?'”

Kat Tenbarge

Kat Tenbarge is a tech and culture press reporter for NBC News Digital.

Read More