Montana lawmakers consider Medicaid rate changes to stop nursing home closures


Wes Thompson, administrator of Valley View Home in the northeastern Montana town of Glasgow, points out regional tax levies and luck as the only factors his proficient nursing center has actually prevented the fate of the 11 retirement home that closed in the state in 2015.

Valley County, with a population of simply over 7,500, passed levies to support the assisted living home totaling up to an approximated $300,000 every year for 3 years, beginning this year. And when the Hi-Line Retirement Center in surrounding Phillips County closed down in 2015 as the COVID-19 pandemic brought more stress factors to the retirement home market, Valley View Home took in a few of its clients.

Related: Transitions to post-acute care are getting back at more tough

Thompson stated he predicts more retirement home closures on the horizon as their monetary battles continue. Legislators are attempting to lower that threat through procedures that would raise and set requirements for the Medicaid compensation rates that nursing houses depend on for their operations.

A research study commissioned by the last legal session discovered that Medicaid suppliers in Montana were being repaid at rates much lower than the expense of care. In his two-year state spending plan proposition prior to legislators, Gov. Greg Gianforte ( R) has actually proposed boosts to the company rates that disappoint the research study’s suggestions.

Legislators preparing the state health department budget plan consisted of rates greater than the guv’s proposition, however still insufficient for nursing houses to cover the expense of offering care. Those rates go through alter as the state budget plan expense goes through the months-long legal procedure, though majority-Republican legislators up until now have actually turned down Democratic legislators’ efforts for complete financing.

In a different effort to deal with the long-lasting care market’s long-lasting practicality, a bipartisan costs going through Montana’s legislature, Senate Bill 296, intends to modify how assisted living home and helped living centers are moneyed The costs would direct health authorities to think about inflation, cost-of-living changes, and the real expenses of services in setting Medicaid repayment rates.

SB 296, which got a preliminary hearing on Feb. 17, has actually produced clashing viewpoints from professionals in the long-lasting care field on whether it does enough to prevent assisted living home closures.

State Sen. Becky Beard (R), the costs’s sponsor, stated that although the costs comes far too late for the retirement home that have actually currently closed, she sees it as shining a light on an issue that’s not disappearing.

” We require to stop the attrition,” Beard stated.

Related: How post-acute care centers utilize innovation to conserve time, battle burnout

Sebastian Martinez Hickey, a research study assistant at the Economic Policy Institute, a not-for-profit think tank, stated incomes for retirement home staff members had actually been very low even prior to the pandemic. He stated the focus requires to be on raising Medicaid compensation rates beyond inflationary aspects.

” Increasing Medicaid rates for inflation is going to have favorable results, however there’s no chance that it’s going to make up for what we’ve experienced in the last numerous years,” Martinez Hickey stated.

Colorado, Illinois, Massachusetts, and North Carolina are amongst the states that have actually embraced laws or policies to increase assisted living home personnel incomes given that the pandemic started. Michigan, North Carolina, and Ohio embraced boosts or one-time rewards.

In Maine, a 2020 research study of long-lasting care labor force concerns recommended that Medicaid rates must be high adequate to support direct-care employee salaries that total up to a minimum of 125% of the base pay, which is $1380 because state. In mix with other objectives described in the research study, after a year there had actually been modest boosts in property care houses and beds, enhanced tenancy rates, and nods towards stabilization of the direct-care labor force.

Rose Hughes, executive director of the Montana Health Care Association, which lobbies on behalf of retirement home and senior concerns, stated much of the issues pestering senior care boil down to compensation rates. There’s insufficient cash to work with personnel, and, if there were, incomes would still be too low to bring in personnel in a competitive market, Hughes stated.

” It’s attempting to handle systemic issues that exist in the system so that longer term the repayment system can be more steady,” Hughes stated.

The guv’s workplace stated Gianforte has actually been clear that Montana requires to raise its supplier rates. For senior and long-lasting care, Gianforte’s suggested state budget plan would raise company rates to 88% of the benchmark advised by the state-commissioned research study. Gianforte’s spending plan proposition is a beginning point for legislators, and legal spending plan authors have actually booked financing at about 90% of the benchmark rate.

” The guv continues to deal with lawmakers and invites their input on his historical company rate financial investment,” Gianforte representative Kaitlin Price stated.

Not a Modern Healthcare customer? Register today.

State Rep. Mary Caferro ( D) is sponsoring an expense to totally money the Medicaid service provider rates in accordance with the research study.

” What we actually, truly require is our costs to pass so that it brings companies existing with continuous financing for predictability and stability so they can do the great of looking after individuals,” Caferro stated at a Feb. 21 press instruction.

But Thompson stated that even the compensation rate advised by the research study– $279 per client, daily, compared to the existing $208 rate– isn’t high enough to cover Valley View Home’s costs. He stated he’s going to need to have a “heart to heart” with the center’s board to see what can be done to keep it open if the regional tax levies in mix with the brand-new rate aren’t enough to cover the expense of operations.

David Trost, CEO of St. John’s United, an assisted-living center for elders in Billings, stated the present repayment rate is so low that St. John’s usages cost savings, grants, fundraising income, and other financial investments to comprise the distinction. He stated that while SB 296 takes a look at aspects to cover operating expense, it does not represent other expenses, such as repair work and restorations.

” In addition to spending for existing operating expense as preferred by SB 296, we likewise require to take a look at financing of capital enhancements through some loan system to assist nursing centers make enhancements to existing environments,” Trost stated.

Another element of SB 296 looks for to increase assisted-living services by creating more federal financing.

Additional cash might help in reducing or remove the waiting list for assisted-living houses, which now stands at about 175 individuals, Hughes stated. That waiting list not just signifies that some senior citizens aren’t getting service, however it likewise leads to more individuals being sent out to nursing houses when they might not require that level of care.

SB 296 would likewise guarantee that cash appropriated to nursing houses can be utilized just for nursing houses, and not be readily available for other programs within the Department of Public Health and Human Services, like dental practitioners, health centers, or Medicaid growth. According to Hughes, in 2021 the assisted living home spending plan had a rest of $29 million, which was moved to various programs in the Senior and Long Term Care department.

If the financing secure in SB 296 had actually remained in location at that time, Hughes stated, there might have been more cash to sustain the assisted living home that closed in 2015.

Keely Larson is the KHN fellow for the UM Legislative News Service, a collaboration of the University of Montana School of Journalism, the Montana Newspaper Association, and Kaiser Health News. Larson is a college student in ecological and natural deposits journalism at the University of Montana.

Kaiser Health News is a nationwide health policy news service. It is an editorially independent program of the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation which is not connected with Kaiser Permanente.

Read More